Model | reversible | irreversible | Algorithm | Population | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Min | Avg | Std. Dev. | Min | Avg | Std. Dev. |  |  |
GMAK | 20.326 | 20.742 | 0.501 | 25.745 | 34.472 | 15.285 | PSO linear 3, Ï•1 = Ï•2 = 2.05 | 25 |
 | 20.403 | 21.787 | 1.297 | 25.183 | 31.694 | 13.255 | DE, f = 0.8, λ = 0.5, CR = 0.3 | 100 |
 | 21.975 | 23.812 | 1.604 | 24.741 | 49.045 | 21.285 | binGA, adaptive MUT, no CROSS | 250 |
 | 24.321 | 27.598 | 2.091 | 30.704 | 35.670 | 3.125 | cmaES | (5+25) |
GMM | 20.280 | 22.818 | 2.186 | 24.857 | 27.978 | 9.146 | DE, f = 0.8, λ = 0.5, CR = 0.5 | 100 |
 | 20.312 | 21.272 | 0.461 | 24.553 | 58.957 | 17.253 | PSO star, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = 2.05 | 25 |
 | 21.649 | 24.628 | 1.801 | 24.616 | 40.896 | 25.881 | binGA, adaptive MUT, one-point CROSS | 250 |
 | 23.890 | 26.624 | 1.851 | 26.414 | 31.136 | 9.052 | cmaES | (5+25) |
CKMM | 20.100 | 21.434 | 0.563 | 21.511 | 26.077 | 7.729 | PSO grid3, Ï•1 = Ï•2 = 2.05 | 25 |
 | 20.862 | 22.499 | 1.119 | 21.763 | 23.603 | 1.268 | DE, f = λ = 0.8, CR = 0.3 | 100 |
 | 21.431 | 23.222 | 1.066 | 25.632 | 28.055 | 2.697 | cmaES | (10, 50) |
 | 22.092 | 23.353 | 0.666 | 25.040 | 25.346 | 0.176 | binGA, adaptive MUT, no CROS | 100 |