A multi-tissue type genome-scale metabolic network for analysis of whole-body systems physiology
© Bordbar et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 28 July 2011
Accepted: 31 October 2011
Published: 31 October 2011
Genome-scale metabolic reconstructions provide a biologically meaningful mechanistic basis for the genotype-phenotype relationship. The global human metabolic network, termed Recon 1, has recently been reconstructed allowing the systems analysis of human metabolic physiology and pathology. Utilizing high-throughput data, Recon 1 has recently been tailored to different cells and tissues, including the liver, kidney, brain, and alveolar macrophage. These models have shown utility in the study of systems medicine. However, no integrated analysis between human tissues has been done.
To describe tissue-specific functions, Recon 1 was tailored to describe metabolism in three human cells: adipocytes, hepatocytes, and myocytes. These cell-specific networks were manually curated and validated based on known cellular metabolic functions. To study intercellular interactions, a novel multi-tissue type modeling approach was developed to integrate the metabolic functions for the three cell types, and subsequently used to simulate known integrated metabolic cycles. In addition, the multi-tissue model was used to study diabetes: a pathology with systemic properties. High-throughput data was integrated with the network to determine differential metabolic activity between obese and type II obese gastric bypass patients in a whole-body context.
The multi-tissue type modeling approach presented provides a platform to study integrated metabolic states. As more cell and tissue-specific models are released, it is critical to develop a framework in which to study their interdependencies.
Metabolism has been implicated in most major human diseases including obesity, diabetes, cancer, and heart disease . Thus, metabolism has been a field of study integral to many branches of medicine. In particular, obesity, a leading preventable cause of death, increases the likelihood of heart disease and diabetes, and represents one of the most serious current public health care problems . Studying and understanding such systemic diseases however requires a fundamental and comprehensive analysis of not only the individual tissues and cell types, but also their integrated functions and interlinked interactions. Accurate physiological representation and analysis of systemic diseases however cannot be achieved unless an integrated multilevel and comprehensive modeling approach is undertaken and the appropriate computational infrastructure is fully developed and utilized.
Genome-scale metabolic network reconstructions have been shown to provide an appropriate context for analyzing biological content . Metabolic reconstructions are important for elucidating the genotype to phenotype relationship and have proved to be useful in interpreting high-throughput, omic data sets . Genome-scale networks can account for a combination of genetic and physiological data . Metabolic networks are built in a bottom-up approach, consisting of the known genes, transcripts, proteins, reactions, and metabolites. Recently, a global human metabolic network (Recon 1) was reconstructed . Recon 1 is a comprehensive map of all the known annotated metabolic reactions of human cells, containing 1496 genes, 3402 intracellular reactions, and 2785 metabolites.
Recon 1 was developed to provide a global genome-scale description of human metabolic capabilities, without consideration of tissue-specific information. As particular cells in the human body do not use all the metabolic capabilities encoded on the genome, procedures have been developed to tailor Recon 1 to tissue and cell specific functions [6–8]. Models for the human liver [8, 9], kidney , brain , erythrocyte , and alveolar macrophage  have been developed. To study diabetes in obese individuals, three tissue-specific reconstructions of the liver (hepatocyte), skeletal muscle (myocyte), and adipose tissue (adipocyte) were developed in this study. The liver plays the biggest role in metabolism, with many functions including gluconeogenesis, glycogen storage, urea production and ketogenesis. Though the liver consists of many different cell types, the major cell type pertaining to metabolism is the hepatocyte. Skeletal muscle, one of the most abundant tissues in the human body, has high metabolic requirements, and plays a major role in protein metabolism and storage. Adipose tissue plays a major role in lipid metabolism and storage. Skeletal muscle and adipose tissue primarily consist of myocytes and adipocytes, respectively.
Results and Discussion
To clearly convey the characteristics and capabilities of the three cell-specific reconstructions and the integrated multi-tissue type network, the results presented here are split into three distinctive sections.
The reconstruction, the content, the quality controls, and the properties of the individual hepatocyte, myocyte, and adipocyte metabolic networks (designated as HM, MM, AM, respectively) are detailed.
The process of building the integrated multi-tissue type network is described and the integrated network is used to compute and compare three established metabolic states (i.e., the Cori cycle, the Alanine cycle, and the absorptive or post-feeding state).
Expression-profiling data was utilized to build two context-specific multi-tissue type models detailing metabolism in i) obese vs ii) diabetic obese individuals to ascertain their differences.
The content of the cell-specific metabolic network reconstruction
The models were tested for internal pathway cycles that could generate excess energy when all exchanges were closed. Appropriate changes were made to the model to remove all futile cycles.
All extraneous dead end and gap-containing pathways were removed to build fully functional networks.
All reactions were elementally and charge balanced and none of the metabolic pathways were lumped into single reactions.
Published data for the different tissues was used to define biomass objective functions (see Additional File 1). The biomass functions were used as maintenance lower bounds for all cell-specific and multi-tissue type simulations.
A detailed description of the cell-network reconstruction pipeline, manual curation, removal of futile cycles, and biomass definition is provided in the Methods section. In general, the processes for generating quality controlled and functional reconstructions of metabolism are well established and available elsewhere [15, 16]. The workflows used to generate the multi-tissue type model adhere to these established procedures.
Global and cell-specific validation using network models for assessing functional states
In order to validate the three cell-specific networks, universal testing was completed for quality control and assurance purposes. Universal testing consisted of validating general metabolic functions of the human cells. The ability to produce precursor metabolites of major metabolic pathways from glucose was confirmed. Production of the nine non-essential amino acids, two conditionally essential amino acids, the fatty acids, nucleotides, glycogen, and cholesterol was also validated. Finally, the three cell-specific models were checked for production of biomass, representing cell growth.
After global testing, cell-specific functions were tested. Cell-specific lipid production of each of the metabolic models was validated. The hepatocyte has many metabolic functions such as gluconeogenesis, ketogenesis, urea and bile production, and glycogen storage. For the HM, we validated that the metabolic network could synthesize glucose from gluconeogenic substrates, such as amino acids, glycerol, lactate, and pyruvate. The pathways for ketogenesis were not included in Recon 1, but were added to the HM to produce ketone bodies. The HM's ability to use alternative sugars as energy sources, complete the urea cycle, and process nitrogen to produce urea was also validated. Fat cells store energy as triglycerides and other lipids. For the AM, the cell-specific model's ability to generate lactate, glycerol, and fatty acids from glucose and triacylglycerol was validated. Finally, skeletal muscle facilitates movement in the body by converting chemical energy into mechanical energy. For the MM, the network's ability to produce ATP from glucose, branched chain amino acids, ketone bodies, glycogen, and fatty acids was validated. In addition, a cell-specific objective function was constructed that utilizes ATP to model the metabolic toll of muscle contraction.
The final cell-specific reconstructions and mathematical models and a full breakdown of every universal and cell-specific test is provided in the Supplementary Material (see Additional Files 2, 3, 4).
Characterizing the cell-specific networks
After an extensive QC/QA procedure, the three cell-specific metabolic networks were characterized and tested for network capabilities (Figure 1B). While the models contain a relatively similar number of metabolites and reactions, the HM has the largest model among all three. This difference is due to the HM's diverse metabolic capabilities that has been captured in the model. For all simulations, the biomass function of each of the metabolic models was set to a physiologically relevant lower bound determined from the cells' in vitro growth rate [17–19]. A lower bound was set in order to simulate regular cellular maintenance such as protein, mRNA, and lipid turnover as well as DNA repair and ATP maintenance requirements. To examine the models, the minimum required amount of carbon was calculated for each of the models to match its in vitro growth rate. This value shows the metabolic requirement for each of the individual cells to be viable. The HM has a much greater need for carbon than the other networks to maintain the in vitro growth rate (Figure 1B). This greater need is not due solely to the higher set growth rate. Though the lower bound of the HM's growth rate is set roughly two and a half times higher than the AM's, the HM's non-glucose carbon uptake is almost seven times as much showing a higher varied metabolic need from the extra-system to function.
Comparing the cell-specific networks
The three cell-specific reconstructions were also compared based on the assigned subsystems and reactions. The reactions of each model were grouped into subsystems (Figure 3A). The majority of reactions in all of the networks corresponded to transporters and lipid metabolism. As the AM has the least metabolic variation and the smallest network, it has the lowest number of reactions in most subsystems except for lipid metabolism. The hepatocyte is the most metabolically active and performs the most metabolic functions of the three cell types. Hence, the HM has the most reactions in each subsystem except for cofactor metabolism. The MM has the most reactions corresponding to cofactor metabolism, due to the skeletal myocyte's high conversion of cofactors for producing chemical energy. Compared to Recon 1, which consists of 3,311 metabolic and transporter reactions, the three cell-specific models have much fewer reactions. The network content and functional scope captured in the cell-specific models reflects specific tissue function with focus on developing high quality metabolic models, as compared with comprehensive but less functional metabolic maps. The three cell-specific reconstructions share a core network of 349 reactions (Figure 3B), which represents the majority of the metabolic reactions in all of the models. Of the remaining reactions, the majority is unique to each cell-specific model. The HM shares a substantial number of reactions with the AM and MM (54 and 74 respectively), while the AM and MM share only six reactions that are not in the HM. Thus, as expected, the three cell-specific metabolic models have functional metabolic uniqueness, but require the same core reactions for basal functionality.
Network integration: connecting the cell-specific reconstructions through a blood compartment
After validation and characterization of the metabolic models on an individual level, the next step was to simulate the integrated metabolic function of all three cell-types. As the three cell-types represent the most important metabolically active cells of their respective tissues, the integrated modeling and simulations are termed multi-tissue modeling and simulation.
Forming a multi-tissue model
As the inputs are relative rather than absolute, the fluxes were normalized to the amount of carbon input. Using this reference point, the percentages of uptakes and secretions presented below demonstrate the physiological behavior. In addition, because the liver, adipose tissue, and skeletal muscle have different masses, the canonical units for genome-scale reconstructions, mmol/h/g cell DW, cannot be used. Using the g cell DW portion of the units assumes that reactions in all three tissues have the same mass. Such an assumption would skew the intercellular fluxes. In order to account for the mass discrepancy in different tissues, the units were changed to mmol/h/body by modifying the biomass objective functions to represent the entire maintenance of each tissue (see Methods).
The Alanine and Cori cycles are physiologically relevant metabolic cycles, but they do not occur exclusively physiologically. In order to amplify and study each one separately, constraints were set on the MM's ability to produce either alanine or lactate and hence affect HM substrate utilization. An unconstrained assessment of MM production and HM use of alanine and lactate to produce glucose and urea in the liver is presented in the Supplementary Material (Additional File 5).
Metabolic state 1: the Alanine cycle
The Alanine cycle is an important physiological cycle that occurs between the myocyte and hepatocyte under glucose limiting conditions . The cycle's function is to eliminate nitrogen from the myocyte and transport it to the hepatocyte for degradation as urea in exchange for energy in the form of glucose. In the liver, alanine is deaminated into pyruvate, which serves as a substrate for gluconeogenesis. In return, glucose is supplied from the liver to skeletal muscle. The multi-tissue simulation consists of the HM, MM, and the blood compartment. In this condition, alanine was imported from the extra-system, i.e., the blood stream (Figure 5A). The HM imports alanine and produces both glucose and urea. The carbon conversion is not one-to-one due to the maintenance requirements of the HM. The carbon split becomes 47:18:35 for glucose, urea, and cellular maintenance requirements, respectively. Taking into account the cellular maintenance requirements provides a more realistic carbon conversion of the Alanine cycle.
The flux spans of the individual HM and MM were investigated and compared to the multi-tissue simulation (Figure 5). For the individual models, the same multi-tissue simulation setup was used but all reactions in the other cell types were inactivated. It became immediately apparent that the two cells metabolically interact with one another. For the Alanine and Cori cycle simulations, because carbon is recycled between the liver and muscle, the extra-system exchanges were not open for carbon sources to exit the blood, thus the individual cell-type models simulations yielded only infeasible solutions. When simulating the individual cell-type models, the exchanges with the extra-system had to be opened for a proper mass balanced steady-state solution.
Flux span and number of reactions participating in internal loops and carrying zero and fixed fluxes of individual and multi-tissue models
Individual HM (Alanine)
Individual MM (Alanine)
Individual HM (Cori)
Individual MM (Cori)
Individual AM (Absorptive)
Individual HM (Absorptive)
Individual MM (Absorptive)
Metabolic state 2: the Cori cycle
The Cori cycle is a metabolic cycle, similar to the Alanine cycle, that metabolically connects the peripheral tissues with the liver . Lactate acts as substrate for hepatic gluconeogenesis. As with alanine in the Alanine cycle, lactate is taken up by the liver and is converted into pyruvate, in this case by lactate dehydrogenase. Unlike the Alanine cycle, no major byproducts (e.g. urea) are generated, and thus the Cori cycle is a cycle of energy transfer between two tissues. The Cori cycle simulation involves the HM, MM, and blood compartment. It is set up with an input of lactate into the blood from the extra-system (Figure 5B). The Cori cycle's efficiency was validated using flux balance analysis of the integrated multi-tissue model. The HM takes up lactate and converts it into glucose. The remainder of the carbon is used for cell maintenance purposes, as described earlier. The carbon split for this cycle is 57:43 for glucose and maintenance respectively. Lacking a byproduct, the cycle converts about 10% more carbon into glucose for the peripheral tissues than the Alanine cycle.
As before, the flux span of the multi-tissue simulation and individual cell-type models was compared (Figure 5). The approach was used as before with similar results. The solution space had shrunk, and the number of zero fluxes had dropped in the multi-tissue simulation. The similarity in results is due to the fact that the two cycles having similar physiological purposes. The HM takes up a gluconeogenic substrate and produces glucose for the MM in a glucose-poor environment.
Metabolic state 3: the absorptive state
The final multi-tissue simulation presented, the absorptive state, is physiologically different than two metabolic cycles already discussed. Thus different results were obtained when investigating its flux span. The absorptive state is an anabolic process during which absorbed glucose is used by the human body to produce glycogen, triaclglyerol, and amino acids . Metabolic function of the liver during the absorptive state is closely linked to the adipose tissue and skeletal muscle for energy storage (Figure 6A).
During the absorptive state, carbohydrates and proteins in food are primarily absorbed as monosaccharides (i.e., essentially glucose) and amino acids. The liver absorbs a fraction of the blood glucose and the rest is taken up by peripheral tissues in the body to generate ATP for energy maintenance requirements. In addition to energy generation, the absorbed glucose is stored as triacylglycerol in the adipose tissue and as glycogen and proteins in the muscle tissue. The excess glucose in the liver is similarly stored as glycogen and triacylglycerol, however unlike the adipocyte, only a small amount of the synthesized triacylglycerol is stored in the liver and the rest is transported to adipose tissue.
An absorptive multi-tissue simulation was performed and consisted of the three cell types, HM, MM, AM, and blood compartment connecting them. Nutrients were absorbed from the extra-system entering the blood compartment. Absolute values for glucose uptake rates were taken from literature . In vivo amino acid levels in the blood are elevated between two- to seven-fold during the absorptive state . Assuming that the minimum requirement of amino acids for biomass maintenance is the baseline level in the blood, the amino acid influx was scaled between two to seven times depending on the specific amino acid. Fatty acids were similarly scaled, in the absence of specific data.
Due to the many metabolic objectives of the absorptive state, for simulation, a Pareto optimality approach was used . Briefly, this optimization framework involves optimizing for a specific objective, then fixing that flux, then optimizing for another objective. If there are more than two objectives, the process is repeated. First, AM triacylglycerol production was optimized and the resulting flux was fixed. Then, a baseline level of amino acid production by the MM was set. The amino acid lower bound for the MM was scaled to a ratio similar to the MM biomass amino acid makeup. Finally, concurrent production of glycogen in the HM and MM was optimized.
When comparing the multi-tissue absorptive flux span with the individual models in similar conditions, there were some differences as compared to the Cori and Alanine cycles (Figure 6B). Initially, the individual AM flux span could not be calculated due to its inability to produce as much triacylglycerol as the set lower bound for the multi-tissue simulation. The glucose uptake of the AM was set from a physiological constraint , limiting triacylglycerol production. To reach the triacylglycerol production lower bound, the HM converts some of its glucose to triacylglycerol precursors that are then transported to the AM, very similar to what occurs physiologically . Because the multi-tissue simulation does not have a triacylglycerol lipoprotein transporter, the fatty acid precursors were formed by the HM and transported to the AM for maximal triacylglycerol production. In the individual AM, fatty acid uptake was increased to complete the study. The HM providing fatty acids to the AM for triacylglycerol has two consequences on the solution space: 1) the multi-tissue HM's solution space is highly constrained compared to that of the HM for the individual hepatic cell-type, while 2) the multi-tissue AM solution space is much larger than for the individual cell-type AM. Despite these differences, on the whole, the mean flux span of all three networks is reduced. There were also a larger number of fixed fluxes in the multi-tissue simulation, due to the higher interdependence between the three cell-specific models. The absorptive state is not limiting and all input metabolites were provided in excess. When simulating the individual models, there were very few to no fixed fluxes in the individual models due to the non-limiting constraints.
Recap of results for the three multi-tissue metabolic state computations
Three physiologically relevant cycles were simulated using the multi-tissue approach. The flux span computations yielded two main results: 1) the intracellular dependence between different cell types in a multi-cellular organism and 2) the transfer of fatty acids to the AM from the HM. Multi-tissue models can provide a platform for mapping isotopomer flux measurements to further increase quantitative accuracy of physiological cycles and holistically understand human metabolism.
Metabolic Differences in Obese and Diabetic Obese Individuals
A major application of genome-scale reconstructions is providing a systems context for integrating high-throughput data, also known as "context for content" . Transcriptomics and proteomics can be appropriately mapped onto the reactions of metabolic networks to allow for a systems analysis of the data.
The metabolic differences between i) obese and ii) Type II diabetes obese individuals were analyzed using the multi-tissue type model developed above. Transcriptomic data was obtained from adipose, liver, and skeletal muscle tissue samples of gastric bypass surgery patients in a fasting state (see Methods). In order to properly simulate the flux conditions, a baseline metabolic state was established. The absorptive state was adapted to simulate a prolonged starvation state. To perform this analysis, the objectives of the absorptive state (AM triaclyglycerol production and MM protein production) were converted into the inputs of the system and the objective was set as the HM glucose production. The changes in the multi-tissue simulation provide a functional backdrop to analyze the obese and Type II diabetes obese states.
There is a considerable difference in reaction activity between the two context-specific states (Figure 7B). 29 reactions are present only in the normal obese model while 94 reactions are present only in the diabetic obese model. The majority of the reaction activity difference is in the AM. In addition, the multi-tissue models were required for providing proper context for the gene expression data. Ignoring the reconstruction context, the gene expression data predicted 27 and 40 exclusively expressed reactions in the normal and diabetic obese patients, respectively. 39 of the 67 expression predicted reactions were not differentially active in the context-specific models. This difference was due to either the unexpressed reaction being added back in for growth rate requirements or that the expressed reaction was a false-positive in terms of the entire network. Thus, the context-specific models predicted 95 differentially expressed reactions due to stoichiometric and flux constraints that the expression data could not solely predict.
The reaction activity changes determined by the context-specific networks can be grouped into three main categories, as detailed below. The first two categories were differences that were not necessarily obvious, but understandable through known macroscopic physiological changes found in diabetic patients. Importantly, the multi-tissue model provides mechanistic explanations as to why the macroscopic physiological changes occurred. These two groups can be viewed as validations of the multi-tissue model and the importance of using a reconstruction, as almost all of the predictions made were not evident in the expression data. The third group consists of one reaction that was completely non-obvious and provides new and interesting metabolic insights into diabetes in obese individuals. A full listing of all differentially active reactions found in the expression data and the final context-specific models are provided in the Supplementary Material for further research (see Additional File 6).
The first group of differentially expressed reactions in the context-specific models deal with known metabolites that have elevated blood concentrations in diabetes: free fatty acids and lactate [26–28]. First, the AM diabetic obese model has many active fatty acid oxidation and carnitine shuttle reactions that are not active in the AM normal obese model. The hyperactivity in the diabetes model can be attributed to a diminished insulin response. The diminished insulin response during the fasting state leads to two attributes common in diabetics. There is a lack of regulation of lipolysis, beta-oxidation of triglycerides into free fatty acids, leading to elevated free fatty acid levels  and a lack of regulation of oxidation of fatty acids into acetyl-CoA. The increased breakdown of fatty acids into sugars partially accounts for observed hyperglycemia in diabetics as the fatty acids stimulate gluconeogenesis in the liver . Inhibition of the fatty acid oxidation reactions that lead to the hyperglycemic effect has been previously proposed as a potential method to inhibit the condition .
Second, HM and MM lactate dehydrogenase are solely active in the normal obese patients. The absence of lactate dehydrogenase in diabetic patients is a potential metabolic mechanism for higher levels of lactate in the blood as the liver and muscle are unable to utilize lactate as a carbohydrate source. In addition, the differential activity of lactate dehydrogenase in the simulations demonstrates the power of the context of the multi-tissue simulation. The lactate dehydrogenase reactions were not differentially expressed in the transcription data, but the model provided proper context for predicting proper reaction activity. An individual model simulation would not yield the same results because the degradation of triacylglycerol from the AM and protein from the MM is critical for proper fasting state contextualization. The lack of lactate dehydrogenase can potentially attribute to the macroscopic observation of high levels of lactate in the blood of obese diabetics, as compared to normal obese individuals .
The second group of reactions provides clues into the metabolic mechanisms of oxidative tissue damage seen in diabetic patients . There were changes in catalase reaction activity throughout the three cell-specific portions of the multi-tissue models. Catalase is a ubiquitous enzyme in aerobic organisms. The enzyme decomposes hydrogen peroxide into oxygen and water. Hydrogen peroxide is generated by free radical via superoxide dismutase. In our context-specific models, catalase was solely active in the AM of the diabetic obese model, but was solely active in the MM of the normal obese model. It has been previously shown that the inherited disorders of acatalasemia and hypocatalasaemia, which lead to defective catalase, increase the likelihood of type II diabetes . The proposed mechanism involves pancreatic beta cells, which are susceptible to oxidative damage. Goth and Eaton proposed that defective catalase increases oxidative species, thus destroying pancreatic beta cells. To detect the defect, erythrocyte catalase was studied. However, no previous studies have been done with the activity of healthy catalase enzyme. Simulations show that catalase activity is not present in the skeletal muscle of diabetic obese patients during the fasting state. Absence of catalase in a cell would have a similar functional effect as expression of defective catalase. The absence of catalase activity probably attributes to oxidative tissue damage as well as may play a role in diabetes development.
Thirdly, AM cysteine dioxygenase (CDO) is only active in the normal obese model. CDO has been shown to be an important regulator in cysteine and sulfur metabolism in adipocytes and hepatocytes  but has not been shown to be related to diabetes. HM CDO has activity in both context-specific models because the hepatic version of the enzyme is post-translationally regulated . CDO is very responsive to dietary changes to protein and sulfur amino acid intake in normal individuals. It is responsible for breaking down excess cysteine into other important metabolites, such as pyruvate and taurine. Very little research has been done on CDO in diabetics. Elevated levels of cysteine in tissues have been shown to be cytotoxic and could be another potential mechanism for the observation of tissue damage in diabetic patients. In addition, taurine has been implicated as an important metabolite in diabetes and supplements of taurine have been shown to reduce diabetic symptoms [34, 35]. The lack of CDO reaction activity in the diabetic context-specific model is a potential reason for the diminished taurine concentration.
Fine-grained studies of integrated human metabolic states have proved to be difficult due to complex intracellular and intercellular interactions. The recently available human genome-scale reconstruction, Recon 1 , is a biological knowledgebase for studying intracellular human metabolism that now enables such an undertaking. This paper presents the first effort to build a multi-tissue metabolic network that is global in the sense that all metabolic functions described on the human genome are taken into account. Thus, three cell-specific genome-scale metabolic networks were reconstructed. They were integrated using a multi-tissue modeling approach and the integrated model was used to study physiologically relevant cycles. High-throughput data was integrated in the context of the integrated metabolic network to study differences in obese and diabetic obese individuals. Several findings resulted from this study.
First, using Recon 1 we generated cell-specific reconstructions for three key tissues involved in diabetes and obesity: adipocytes, hepatocytes, and myocytes. The three cell-specific reconstructions were converted into mathematical models and put through stringent testing to validate tissue-specific physiological functions.
Second, intercellular metabolic interactions were then described by developing a multi tissue-type modeling paradigm that combines the cell-specific models through a blood compartment. The multi-tissue model is not simply a trivial sum of the cell-specific reconstructions. As an example, a bicarbonate buffering system was required to simulate the mathematical model.
Third, using the multi-tissue models, simulations for the Alanine and Cori cycles and the absorptive state are possible. These three physiologically relevant cycles are presented. When comparing the nutrient limited cycles to the individual models (e.g. Alanine and Cori cycles), the multi-tissue simulation approach showed a constrained solution space. In a nutrient rich environment (e.g. absorptive state), the HM and MM were constrained while the AM was not. The AM is not as metabolically independent as the HM and MM and thus gains potential phenotypes when integrated with the other metabolic reconstructions.
Fourth, utilizing the multi-tissue approach, the metabolic differences in obese and diabetic obese individuals were studied by incorporating gene expression data as a constraint on the metabolic networks. The approach was validated and provided potential mechanisms for known macroscopic physiological changes seen in diabetic patients such as increased blood metabolite concentrations and oxidative damage of tissues. In addition, cysteine dioxygenase was found to be differentially active and could be a potential factor in oxidative damage to tissues and lower concentrations of taurine in adipose and liver tissues. The differences in the two context-specific models were not obvious and required the multi-tissue modeling approach, as the differential activity of reactions could not be ascertained from the transcription data alone.
The first genome-scale metabolic network reconstructed was H. influenzae, representing the first sequenced prokaryote . Other prokaryotic genome-scale metabolic networks have been reconstructed (e.g. M. tuberculosis [37, 38], H. pylori , S. aureus ). The most notable prokaryotic reconstruction is that for E. coli with many successive expansions [41–43]. The next step was reconstructing a eukaryotic cell, with the introduction of the S. cerevisiae metabolic network . With the need for understanding human metabolism for the health sciences, Recon 1 was introduced. Recon 1 is a comprehensive knowledge base for human cells allowing integration of high-throughput data to build cell type specific models. In this study, a multi-tissue type modeling approach is detailed that allows for an increased understanding of intercellular interactions. Integrating high-throughput data allows for the study of pathophysiological states. Multi-tissue simulations can provide a basis for designing isotopomer flux experiments and allow for mapping flux results onto the network. Utilizing the multi-tissue models for designing and analyzing flux experiments can increase the accuracy and quantitative utility of the multi-tissue approach, further expanding the usefulness and necessity of genome-scale metabolic networks for studying the health sciences.
Building a Tissue Specific Metabolic Model
Using the human genome sequence and annotation, biochemical, and physiological data available through online databases and published literature, three metabolic networks were reconstructed for the human hepatocyte, myocyte, and adipocyte. A workflow for this procedure is shown in Figure 2. We began with tailoring Recon 1. The gene index was updated from Build 35 to Build 36.2 (the current release at the time). The GeneID numbers in Recon 1 are not unique and were replaced by the unique RefSeq transcript IDs. All transporters and lumped reactions were redone with proper elemental and proton balancing. Tissue specificity information was obtained from the UniProt (Universal Protein Resource) database . An automated draft model was reconstructed in SimPheny from the cell-specific open reading frames determined from UniProt and the updated Recon 1 model.
The draft models were finalized through manual curation. Metabolic pathways in each cell type were included based on the existing knowledge of cell physiology and cell-specific biomass requirements. For each pathway, the presence of each reaction was supported by one or more of the following information obtained from online databases and/or published literature: biochemical data, genetic data, localization data, sequence data, physiological data, and modeling data. Reaction properties were verified through online databases such as KEGG  (for stoichiometry and cofactor specificity), NCBI (for organism specificity), UniProt (for localization), and BRENDA  (for reversibility, localization, and tissue-specificity). Presence, mechanism, and localization of metabolic pathways were also verified using textbook references [48–51] and tissue specific gene expression data (cDNA library, NCBI). If possible, reactions with dead-end substrates and products were deleted from, or interconnected within, the network to reduce metabolic gaps. Pathways for synthesis of known essential cell components, including the essential amino acids, vitamins, and fatty acids, were removed if present, and appropriate transport reactions were included to allow the uptake of the essential cell components into the network. Additional metabolic pathways that were not included in Recon 1 but were present in the tissue specific models were also added at this stage. For example, ketogenesis is present in the HM but not in Recon 1 and was accordingly added to the reconstruction. To preserve a standardized QC/QA procedure for building the three networks, the HM was not augmented with previously published liver metabolic reconstructions [8, 9]. The additional hepatic metabolism covered in these two models is outside of the scope of multi-tissue interactions studied. A comparison of the two previous models and the one in this study is presented in the Supplementary Material (Additional File 7).
Biomass maintenance functions were constructed for the three cell-specific metabolic models. The process involved gathering primary literature data on the metabolic make up of the human tissue or related mammals if human-specific data was scarce. The overall process of formulating biomass objective functions for eukaryotes has been described in previous publications . The composition of the HM is broken down into proteins, neutral lipids, phospholipids, glycogen, DNA, and RNA. The MM biomass function consists of non-collagen protein, collagen protein, lipids, DNA, RNA, and glycogen. The AM is composed of carbohydrates protein, lipids, DNA, and RNA (Figure 1C). A full breakdown of each macromolecular component and final weighting in the objective function is provided in the Supplementary Material (see Additional File 1).
Integrating Metabolic Models
The overall compartment schematic of the integrated multi-tissue model is presented in Figure 4. There were two main steps for integration: mathematical integration and blood compartment refinement. For the first step, the reactions and metabolites in the three cell-specific models were renamed for proper compartmentalization. A new blood compartment representing the interstitial fluid, urine, and blood was constructed. The exchanges of the cell-specific models were removed and only gene-associated transporters and free diffusion allow for intercellular metabolite transport. Exchange reactions were added to allow the blood compartment to uptake and secrete metabolites into the extra-system. The second step involved refining the blood compartment. It was not possible to properly simulate using flux balance analysis due to improper proton balancing. A bicarbonate buffer reaction, similar to the function of the kidney, was added to account for proton balancing.
Other metabolic changes and degradation in the blood were assumed to be negligible due to the large time-scale differences between small metabolite stability in whole blood versus the amount of time a metabolite spends in the blood for transport. In particular, Liu et al. have shown through time course metabolomic profiling of plasma drawn from incubated whole blood that most small metabolites accounted for in the multi-tissue model's blood compartment are stable (25 of 33 metabolites showed no significant change in the 4 hr study) . The rest of the metabolites are stable until the later time points, except for pyruvate that showed significant change by the first time point (1 hr). All originally detected metabolites were still present at the end of the study. On the other hand, blood circulates throughout the body in about a minute. The microvasculature is structured in a way for convective forces to dominate diffusive forces to increase the rate of uptake of solutes. In particular, metabolic uptake is in the time scale of seconds and minutes . Such a large time scale difference (two to four orders of magnitude) makes blood degradative processes negligible. The metabolites spend only a few minutes in the blood compartment while their degradation takes hours. Thus, the amount of degradation in the blood compartment is negligible as metabolites are primarily located in the cells and tissues and it can be assumed that metabolic changes occur predominantly there.
In the human body, the three tissues have varying masses. Initially, the simulations were set up using the units: mmol/h/g cell DW; which assumes that all three tissues have the same weight. To properly simulate intercellular fluxes, the biomass objective functions were scaled to the units: mmol/h/body. Thus, the three tissue model fluxes were scaled to represent the entire tissue mass in the average human body. The units were scaled by the mass of the tissue [54–56], the cellular composition of the tissue, and subtracting the water weight (see Additional File 1). For the white adipose tissue and skeletal muscle tissue, it was assumed that adipocyte and myocyte were the cells present. For the HM, it was assumed that 80% of the cellular mass of the liver are hepatocytes .
Flux Balance Analysis
Characterizing the extremities of the system's solution space is done using a variant of FBA called flux variability analysis (FVA). FVA involves iteratively and independently determining the minimum and maximum fluxes through the metabolic network. The flux span for a reaction is defined as the difference between the maximum and minimum flux. When analyzing the flux span, we did not consider reactions that were perceived to be part of thermodynamically infeasible internal loops.
Context-Specific Multi-tissue Simulation
Context-specific metabolic networks for obese and diabetic obese individuals were built using the prolonged starvation multi-tissue model and the Gene Inactivity Moderated by Metabolism and Expression (GIMME) algorithm . The GIMME algorithm is a linear programming problem that uses gene expression data to minimize the flux of down regulated genes. The procedure results in a smaller context-specific model built from the original multi-tissue model as unexpressed reactions are removed from the metabolic network. Gene expression data for obese and diabetic obese individuals was obtained through the Gene Expression Omnibus (GSE15773, GSE15653, GSE18732) [59, 60]. Expression data was normalized using GCRMA and presence and absence calls were made using the PANP function in the R statistical platform (p < 0.01) for each patient group (diabetic, non-diabetic) of each tissue (adipose, liver, muscle). For the GIMME simulations, genes were deemed present if they were present within all samples of the particular tissue and group. Before using GIMME, a permutation sensitivity analysis was completed by removing up to 50% of the samples from each tissue and patient group. The expression data was very stable for all groups (see Additional File 8). Flux variability analysis was used to compare which reactions could carry flux in both context-specific models and thus ascertain the metabolic differences in reaction activity between obese and diabetic obese individuals.
We would like to thank Neema Jamshidi and Jake Feala for reading the manuscript and providing critical feedback. Support came from a Phase 2 SBIR (HG002990) from the NHGRI.
- Hsu PP, Sabatini DM: Cancer cell metabolism: Warburg and beyond. Cell. 2008, 134: 703-707. 10.1016/j.cell.2008.08.021.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Barness LA, Opitz JM, Gilbert-Barness E: Obesity: genetic, molecular, and environmental aspects. Am J Med Genet A. 2007, 143A: 3016-3034. 10.1002/ajmg.a.32035.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Oberhardt MA, Palsson BO, Papin JA: Applications of genome-scale metabolic reconstructions. Mol Syst Biol. 2009, 5: 320-PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Joyce AR, Palsson BO: The model organism as a system: integrating 'omics' data sets. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2006, 7: 198-210. 10.1038/nrm1857.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Duarte NC, Becker SA, Jamshidi N, Thiele I, Mo ML, et al, et al.: Global reconstruction of the human metabolic network based on genomic and bibliomic data. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2007, 104: 1777-1782. 10.1073/pnas.0610772104.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Shlomi T, Cabili MN, Herrgard MJ, Palsson BO, Ruppin E: Network-based prediction of human tissue-specific metabolism. Nat Biotechnol. 2008, 26: 1003-1010. 10.1038/nbt.1487.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Becker SA, Palsson BO: Context-specific metabolic networks are consistent with experiments. PLoS Comput Biol. 2008, 4: e1000082-10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000082.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jerby L, Shlomi T, Ruppin E: Computational reconstruction of tissue-specific metabolic models: application to human liver metabolism. Mol Syst Biol. 2010, 6: 401-PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gille C, Bolling C, Hoppe A, Bulik S, Hoffmann S, et al, et al.: HepatoNet1: a comprehensive metabolic reconstruction of the human hepatocyte for the analysis of liver physiology. Mol Syst Biol. 2010, 6: 411-PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chang RL, Xie L, Bourne PE, Palsson BO: Drug off-target effects predicted using structural analysis in the context of a metabolic network model. PLoS Comput Biol. 2010, 6: e1000938-10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000938.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lewis NE, Schramm G, Bordbar A, Schellenberger J, Andersen MP, et al, et al.: Large-scale in silico modeling of metabolic interactions between cell types in the human brain. Nat Biotechnol. 2010, 28: 1279-1285. 10.1038/nbt.1711.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bordbar A, Jamshidi N, Palsson BO: iAB-RBC-283: A proteomically derived knowledge-base of erythrocyte metabolism that can be used to simulate its physiological and patho-physiological states. BMC Syst Biol. 2011, 5: 110-10.1186/1752-0509-5-110.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bordbar A, Lewis NE, Schellenberger J, Palsson BO, Jamshidi N: Insight into human alveolar macrophage and M. tuberculosis interactions via metabolic reconstructions. Mol Syst Biol. 2010, 6: 422-PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Becker SA, Feist AM, Mo ML, Hannum G, Palsson BO, et al, et al.: Quantitative prediction of cellular metabolism with constraint-based models: the COBRA Toolbox. Nat Protoc. 2007, 2: 727-738. 10.1038/nprot.2007.99.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Thiele I, Palsson BO: A protocol for generating a high-quality genome-scale metabolic reconstruction. Nat Protoc. 2010, 5: 93-121.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Feist AM, Herrgard MJ, Thiele I, Reed JL, Palsson BO: Reconstruction of biochemical networks in microorganisms. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2009, 7: 129-143.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nyberg SL, Remmel RP, Mann HJ, Peshwa MV, Hu WS, et al, et al.: Primary hepatocytes outperform Hep G2 cells as the source of biotransformation functions in a bioartificial liver. Ann Surg. 1994, 220: 59-67.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Muguruma Y, Reyes M, Nakamura Y, Sato T, Matsuzawa H, et al, et al.: In vivo and in vitro differentiation of myocytes from human bone marrow-derived multipotent progenitor cells. Exp Hematol. 2003, 31: 1323-1330. 10.1016/j.exphem.2003.09.003.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Van RL, Bayliss CE, Roncari DA: Cytological and enzymological characterization of adult human adipocyte precursors in culture. J Clin Invest. 1976, 58: 699-704. 10.1172/JCI108516.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Marieb EN: Human anatomy & physiology. 2004, New York: Pearson Education, 1242-xxiGoogle Scholar
- Stipanuk MH: Biochemical and physiological aspects of human nutrition. 2000, Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders, 1007-xxxGoogle Scholar
- Thurman RG, Kauffman FC, Jungermann K: Regulation of hepatic metabolism: intra-and intercellular compartmentation. 1986, New York: Plenum Press, 489-xixView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tipton KD, Ferrando AA, Phillips SM, Doyle D, Wolfe RR: Postexercise net protein synthesis in human muscle from orally administered amino acids. Am J Physiol. 1999, 276: E628-634.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Vo TD, Greenberg HJ, Palsson BO: Reconstruction and functional characterization of the human mitochondrial metabolic network based on proteomic and biochemical data. J Biol Chem. 2004, 279: 39532-39540. 10.1074/jbc.M403782200.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Feist AM, Palsson BO: The growing scope of applications of genome-scale metabolic reconstructions using Escherichia coli. Nat Biotech. 2008, 26: 659-667. 10.1038/nbt1401.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hawkins M, Gabriely I, Wozniak R, Reddy K, Rossetti L, et al, et al.: Glycemic control determines hepatic and peripheral glucose effectiveness in type 2 diabetic subjects. Diabetes. 2002, 51: 2179-2189. 10.2337/diabetes.51.7.2179.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Staehr P, Hother-Nielsen O, Levin K, Holst JJ, Beck-Nielsen H: Assessment of hepatic insulin action in obese type 2 diabetic patients. Diabetes. 2001, 50: 1363-1370. 10.2337/diabetes.50.6.1363.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chen YD, Varasteh BB, Reaven GM: Plasma lactate concentration in obesity and type 2 diabetes. Diabete Metab. 1993, 19: 348-354.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Boden G, Shulman GI: Free fatty acids in obesity and type 2 diabetes: defining their role in the development of insulin resistance and beta-cell dysfunction. Eur J Clin Invest. 2002, 32 (Suppl 3): 14-23.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Foley JE: Rationale and application of fatty acid oxidation inhibitors in treatment of diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Care. 1992, 15: 773-784. 10.2337/diacare.15.6.773.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Baynes JW: Role of oxidative stress in development of complications in diabetes. Diabetes. 1991, 40: 405-412. 10.2337/diabetes.40.4.405.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Goth L, Eaton JW: Hereditary catalase deficiencies and increased risk of diabetes. Lancet. 2000, 356: 1820-1821. 10.1016/S0140-6736(00)03238-4.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Stipanuk MH, Ueki I, Dominy JE, Simmons CR, Hirschberger LL: Cysteine dioxygenase: a robust system for regulation of cellular cysteine levels. Amino Acids. 2009, 37: 55-63. 10.1007/s00726-008-0202-y.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hansen SH: The role of taurine in diabetes and the development of diabetic complications. Diabetes Metab Res Rev. 2001, 17: 330-346. 10.1002/dmrr.229.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Franconi F, Di Leo MA, Bennardini F, Ghirlanda G: Is taurine beneficial in reducing risk factors for diabetes mellitus?. Neurochem Res. 2004, 29: 143-150.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Edwards JS, Palsson BO: Systems properties of the Haemophilus influenzae Rd metabolic genotype. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1999, 274: 17410-17416. 10.1074/jbc.274.25.17410.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jamshidi N, Palsson BO: Investigating the metabolic capabilities of Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv using the in silico strain iNJ661 and proposing alternative drug targets. BMC Syst Biol. 2007, 1: 26-10.1186/1752-0509-1-26.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Beste DJ, Hooper T, Stewart G, Bonde B, Avignone-Rossa C, et al, et al.: GSMN-TB: a web-based genome-scale network model of Mycobacterium tuberculosis metabolism. Genome Biol. 2007, 8: R89-10.1186/gb-2007-8-5-r89.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schilling CH, Covert MW, Famili I, Church GM, Edwards JS, et al, et al.: Genome-scale metabolic model of Helicobacter pylori 26695. Journal of Bacteriology. 2002, 184: 4582-4593. 10.1128/JB.184.16.4582-4593.2002.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Becker SA, Palsson BO: Genome-scale reconstruction of the metabolic network in Staphylococcus aureus N315: an initial draft to the two-dimensional annotation. BMC Microbiol. 2005, 5: 8-10.1186/1471-2180-5-8.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Feist AM, Henry CS, Reed JL, Krummenacker M, Joyce AR, et al, et al.: A genome-scale metabolic reconstruction for Escherichia coli K-12 MG1655 that accounts for 1260 ORFs and thermodynamic information. Mol Syst Biol. 2007, 3:Google Scholar
- Reed JL, Vo TD, Schilling CH, Palsson BO: An expanded genome-scale model of Escherichia coli K-12 (iJR904 GSM/GPR). Genome Biology. 2003, 4: R54.51-R54.12.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Edwards JS, Palsson BO: The Escherichia coli MG1655 in silico metabolic genotype: Its definition, characteristics, and capabilities. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2000, 97: 5528-5533. 10.1073/pnas.97.10.5528.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Forster J, Famili I, Fu PC, Palsson BO, Nielsen J: Genome-Scale Reconstruction of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Metabolic Network. Genome Research. 2003, 13: 244-253. 10.1101/gr.234503.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Consortium U: The Universal Protein Resource (UniProt) in 2010. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010, 38: D142-148.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kanehisa M, Goto S: KEGG: kyoto encyclopedia of genes and genomes. Nucleic Acids Res. 2000, 28: 27-30. 10.1093/nar/28.1.27.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chang A, Scheer M, Grote A, Schomburg I, Schomburg D: BRENDA, AMENDA and FRENDA the enzyme information system: new content and tools in 2009. Nucleic Acids Res. 2009, 37: D588-592. 10.1093/nar/gkn820.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Salway JG: Metabolism at a glance. 1999, Oxford; Malden, MA: Blackwell Science, 111-Google Scholar
- Devlin TM: Textbook of biochemistry: with clinical correlations. 1997, New York: Wiley, 1186-xxviiGoogle Scholar
- Bronk J: Human Metabolism: Functional Diversity and Integration. 1999, Harlow: Addison, Wesley, LongmanGoogle Scholar
- Vander AJ, Sherman JH, Luciano DS: Human physiology: the mechanisms of body function. 1994, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1: (various pagings) pGoogle Scholar
- Liu L, Aa J, Wang G, Yan B, Zhang Y, et al, et al.: Differences in metabolite profile between blood plasma and serum. Anal Biochem. 2010, 406: 105-112. 10.1016/j.ab.2010.07.015.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bassingthwaighte JB, Goresky CA: Modeling in the analysis of solute and water exchange in the microvasculature. Edited by: Renkin EM, Michel CC, Geiger SR. 1984, Handbook of physiology Section 2 The cardiovascular system: American Physiological Society, 549-626.Google Scholar
- Janssen I, Heymsfield SB, Wang ZM, Ross R: Skeletal muscle mass and distribution in 468 men and women aged 18-88 yr. J Appl Physiol. 2000, 89: 81-88.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Seeley RR, Stephens TD, Tate P: Essentials of anatomy and physiology. 1999, Boston: WCB/McGraw-Hill, 630-xxvGoogle Scholar
- Deurenberg P, Yap M, van Staveren WA: Body mass index and percent body fat: a meta analysis among different ethnic groups. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 1998, 22: 1164-1171. 10.1038/sj.ijo.0800741.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Al-Rubeai M, Fussenegger M, SpringerLink (Online service): Apoptosis. 2004, Dordrecht; Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 333-ixGoogle Scholar
- Orth JD, Thiele I, Palsson BO: What is flux balance analysis?. Nat Biotechnol. 2010, 28: 245-248. 10.1038/nbt.1614.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Stephens NA, Gallagher IJ, Rooyackers O, Skipworth RJ, Tan BH, et al, et al.: Using transcriptomics to identify and validate novel biomarkers of human skeletal muscle cancer cachexia. Genome Med. 2010, 2: 1-10.1186/gm122.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pihlajamaki J, Boes T, Kim EY, Dearie F, Kim BW, et al, et al.: Thyroid hormone-related regulation of gene expression in human fatty liver. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2009, 94: 3521-3529. 10.1210/jc.2009-0212.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.